In discussions of raising children to being good citizens, there seems to be two sides of the coin: parents who are minimalists, don’t buy their children lots of toys, and don’t want them to be entitled. Then, there are parents who don’t mind giving in to their children’s every whim, whether they want a certain toy, cell phone, or even car.
Of course, there is a middle ground but in my discussions with parents over the last year of being a parent myself, I’ve found that very few people are willing to cut back when it comes to spending on their children.
Of course, the main question is: is spoiling such a bad thing? Also, how will it affect our children long-term?
Differing Opinions in Recent Research
Recent research shows that spoiling children can be detrimental to their overall wellbeing. All Elizabeth Kolbert reported to The New Yorker, “Contemporary American kids may represent the most indulged young people in the history of the world. It’s not just that they’ve been given unprecedented amounts of stuff… They’ve also been granted unprecedented authority.” This “unprecedented authority” that Kolbert describes could be the reason so many young adults lack discipline and end up living with their parents as adults.
Conversely, Alfie Kohn in his book The Myth of the Spoiled Child asserts that children today aren’t entitled or spoiled at all. It’s simply just a result of older generations labeling younger generations with these terms. He believes that despite the bad press “spoiled” children get these days, “today’s youth are more tolerant than their parents and admirably committed to making the world a better place.” So perhaps “spoiling” is just a perception because children have so much more access to opportunities, technology, and the global world than any other generation on the planet today.
What is Spoiling?
Like most parenting questions, this one is bound to get a variety of answers. What might be spoiling to one parent might seem perfectly normal to another. To me, the phrase “spoiling kids” means spending more on your children than the average person in your income bracket. As the chart below shows, people with lower incomes tend to spend 25% of their take home pay on their children whereas people in the highest income brackets spend 12% of their income on their children yearly. Thus, to spoil your children would mean to spend more than these average percentages, more than is typically required to feed, clothe, and educate them.
Contrast that with a friend of mine who had a mother who spoiled her mercilessly. If my friend asked for something, she got it. If her mom said no at first, she would transform into a whiny child, and say “Pleeeeeasseee?” Her mom gave in. Every. Single. Time. My friend knew her parents were wealthy and thought she was entitled to a piece of their income. This continued until she was an adult, and it was a very harsh reality when her parents told her she was now on her own when she graduated from college. In her case, spoiling wasn’t effective because she wasn’t prepared for a future of taking care of herself.
Attaching Meaning to Spoiling
The big difference between my attitude and the attitude of the friend’s parents I mentioned above is that each time we “spoil” our children or give them a little something outside the norm, my husband and I plan to explain why we’re able to do these things. This is the catch I mentioned above. We refuse to just give something to them without them knowing why we’re able to. Hard work and the rewards of hard work are going to be a part of our normal family discussions.
Perhaps having this frame of mind will help avoid some of the problems seen with college aged kids today. A recent study in the American Sociological Review found that “the students least likely to excel are those who essentially receive blank checks for college expenses.” Many of these parents in the study who offered extensive financial help did not have lengthy discussions on expectations, which is likely the biggest part of this problem.
The Limits of Spoiling
Interestingly enough, there are many wealthy families in the US who don’t plan on writing blank checks to their kids at all. These include well-known billionaires like Warren Buffet and Bill Gates who have pledged to give their wealth to charity instead of to their children. Although they will give their children something and Warren Buffet donates money to each of his children’s charities, they’ve decided against leaving their billions to their offspring. They’ve raised their children to do chores, work hard, and eventually earn their fortunes for themselves. I fully support this and admire these families for encouraging their children to work tirelessly to achieve success just as their parents have.
A Quest for Independent Children
Ultimately it comes down to personal preference of the parents when it comes to spoiling. I don’t mind giving my children a little something extra provided they understand why it’s possible and what they have to do to ensure they continue to earn such rewards.
Above anything, my husband and I want our children to be independent and self-starters. Each time we take them to do something they enjoy, we’re going to say things like, “Your Dad and I worked extra hours this year to be able to take this vacation. Vacations are expensive, but because we spent a lot of extra time working, we’re not only able to take time off to see a new place, but we’re able to take the two of you with us.”
It might not seem like children take in these messages but with enough repetition over and over again, slowly an image will form that in order to get the “extras” in life, you have to put in the work ahead of time. Furthermore, as parents we are extending these extras to them, our children, not because we have to but because we want to.
As an aside, I do realize not everyone can afford extras and we’re not necessarily there ourselves, but when we do have the means and our careers do reach a point when extras are possible, it will make us feel good to pass on those rewards to our children provided they are well behaved and work hard enough themselves in school to be rewarded with these opportunities.
Readers, do you believe in spoiling your children or giving them little extras? What does spoiling mean to you?