How To Hack Charitable Giving

in Financial Planning by

Key Takeaways
  • Focus on 1 or 2 causes where you want to make an impact.
  • Make sure your donation will go to a qualified charitable organization with little spent on overhead.
  • Consider donating up to 30% of your appreciated securites to avoid capital gains taxes.

The following post has been updated and was co-authored by Angela Campbell, Chief Executive Officer of Agora Fund.

Thanksgiving has officially kicked-off the holiday season, also known as the most charitable time of the year. In fact, the past two years charitable giving has increased 10% (using inflation-adjusted dollars) and shows no signs of going down this year.

Chances are you’ve already been asked for contributions by no less than three non-profits. Gifts from individuals are crucial to the nonprofit sector (last year individuals gave $353 billion according to Charity Navigator) and can be extremely beneficial to reduce your taxes. But many individual donors aren’t optimizing their gifts – meaning, their donation dollars are not leveraged to achieve maximum social impact and their giving strategy is not in sync with their broader financial strategy.

However, improving the impact of a donation doesn’t require giving more – it requires giving wisely.  By treating giving as part of your financial plan – with a clear strategy, goals, and an eye towards impact – your donations can be both globally impactful and personally beneficial.

Here are four ways to help improve your giving strategy this year.

1. Begin With Your Goal In Mind

In the world of giving, the word legacy comes up all the time. How do you want to leave your mark on the world?

The first step in determining your giving strategy is to define the end-game. Reflect on what you want your legacy to be and the causes that matter most to you. Giving can often be reactive – a friend asks you to donate to support her participation in a marathon, your alma mater calls for your annual contribution, or a nonprofit drops you an email about setting up a tribute fund. These are all wonderful reasons to give, but to really align your results with what you care about, it pays to be strategic.

2. Focus On Results

The second step to giving wisely is to select nonprofits that align with your goals. If you seek to maximize impact, focus on long-term results and evidence of success. By doing so, you avoid funding nonprofits whose budgets are eaten up by costly marketing campaigns and start driving real change in the world.

As individuals with busy schedules, we have a limitation that foils our best intentions to give wisely: time. Evaluating and selecting nonprofits is time and labor-intensive, particularly when many nonprofits do not publicly report key metrics. Before donating, make sure the organization registers as a qualified non-profit.

Given the opaqueness of the nonprofit world, younger generations are increasingly demanding transparency and results. Those of us ages 19 to 49 are nearly twice as likely as prior generations to focus on understanding the “return on investment” of our donations.

3. Determine How Much To Give

How much to give is a personal question. Some of the world’s wealthiest families have committed to giving away the majority of their wealth. Warren Buffet kicked off the Giving Pledge in 2006, committing to give all of his Berkshire Hathaway stock – 99% of his wealth – to charity.

Not all of us can afford to give so much. The Giving Pledge, of course, is for billionaires. Most of us give about 3% of our adjusted gross income (AGI) per year.  As shown in the chart below, giving patterns follow an inverse bell curve: as a percentage of their income, households with the highest and lowest income give the most.

US Average Charitable Giving by Income Level

In reality, to hone in on the right donation number, we need to take into account what we make, what we save, and whether our financial condition is sufficient to meet our ongoing financial needs.

4. Capitalize on Your Tax Benefits

Paying attention to tax benefits can give serious leverage to your giving dollars. Charitable deductions are a gift from the IRS that enable us to deduct up to 50% of our AGI during the tax year a donation is made.

You can capture another tax benefit by giving appreciated securities. The benefits of doing so are twofold, 1) don’t pay capital gains tax on the appreciation of those securities, and 2) you can deduct the full fair market value of the securities (but only up to 30% of your AGI).

To use a simple example, suppose you decided to give $3,000 this year – 3% of your $100,000 income. If you opted to give stocks that your parents had bought for you as a child (let’s say they invested $1,000, which is now worth $3,000), here’s what your tax savings would be:

  • $900 of saved federal income tax (assuming a 30% tax bracket)
  • $300 of saved capital gains tax (assuming a 15% capital gains tax rate)

In this scenario, by giving appreciated securities and itemizing your deductions, you may immediately get a 40% boost in the impact of your dollars.

For those of you who are already taking withdrawals from our IRAs, you’ve got another alternative: if you are at least 70½ by year’s end, you can elect to have all or part of this year’s IRA distribution go to charity, up to $100,000 per year. The tax benefit: you won’t owe income tax on the distribution (but you do not get a deduction).

Gifts All Around

Whether you’re considering giving cash, donating online, or signing checks as a charitable donation this year, it’s important to keep your money’s true impact in mind and give wisely. A giving strategy can be both mutually beneficial and more effective if it’s considered in the context of your financial goals and investing strategies. So before draining your wallet this holiday season, talk to your financial advisor about the best giving strategy for you and your family.

About Agora Fund: Angela Rastegar Campbell founded Agora Fund in 2014 with the goal of building a more transparent marketplace for giving. Agora’s digital platform enables you to determine your giving strategy and ‘end goal’ by matching the causes, regions, and approaches you care about to a custom portfolio of nonprofits. Angela and her team evaluate charities through a rigorous, quantitative process, selecting less than 1% to include in their platform. Individuals receive custom impact reports on the nonprofits in their portfolio. Additionally, Agora helps you capitalize on tax benefits. Individuals who experience a windfall or income spike can frontload donations to their account where funds are held for future giving, and can also donate appreciated securities.

Image credit: Courtney from Flickr Creative Commons

The following two tabs change content below.
Catha Mullen

Catha Mullen

Catha Mullen is passionate about helping people make healthier financial decisions, which is why she joined Personal Capital. Personal Capital helps people live better financial lives by providing technology-enabled advisory services, in addition to free financial software. She's got an MBA from Stanford and AB from Princeton.
Catha Mullen

Latest posts by Catha Mullen (see all)


7 comments

  1. Sophi Sharma

    I a looking for donation to start autistic school in Nepal.We hardly have any facilities for these children.Every month the. Number is on the increase.our government does not even know what autism is.Such is our fate.thanking you.

    Reply
  2. Sophi Sharma

    I a looking for donation to start autistic school in Nepal.We hardly have any facilities for these children.Every month the. Number is on the increase.our government does not even know what autism is.Such is our fate.thanking you.This is genuine no duplicate.

    Reply
  3. Sophie

    This is important, but I would add that overhead spending at a nonprofit or charity is not necessarily a bad thing. How much good does it do to give an organization money if they overexert their administrative employees and leave them without benefits in an attempt to make their budgets stretch further (potentially compromising their ability to raise even more money)? Do a little bit more research before giving and actually learn about the programs that are being accomplished, not just how little is spent on employee salaries and benefits. See this TED talk for more info: http://www.ted.com/talks/dan_pallotta_the_way_we_think_about_charity_is_dead_wrong

    Reply
  4. Physician on FIRE

    Timely article. I like to give via a donor advised fund to get the maximum tax benefit. I give large sums now, while in a high marginal tax bracket, and will give the money away over a lifetime, much of which will be spent in a much lower tax bracket.

    It’s nice to see the capital gains taxes disappear, as well.

    Best,
    Physician on FIRE

    Reply
  5. Tomas Killington

    I have finally reached a place where I feel comfortable enough financially to help others. I hadn’t really considered the different factors that go into charitable donations. I didn’t realize how important it was to find a good nonprofit that has evidence of success so that your donation isn’t wasted on marketing or other costs. Finding a reputable organization with a good website will be my top priority moving forward.

    Reply
  6. Kourtney Jensen

    I really like that you said to select a nonprofit that aligns with your goals. My grandma had breast cancer and my grandpa has leukemia, so I’ve been thinking of doing something to help those causes. I’ll be sure to find an organization that is determined to find a cure for cancers.

    Reply
  7. Alexandria Martinez

    I find that giving to charities is a great way for people who can’t always take time out of their days or lives to do the charitable work themselves to give to those in need. I like that you mention non-profit organizations and the benefits to donating therein. Those donations will make the lives of those affected a lot better.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Disclaimer. This communication and all data are for informational purposes only and do not constitute a recommendation to buy or sell securities. You should not rely on this information as the primary basis of your investment, financial, or tax planning decisions. You should consult your legal or tax professional regarding your specific situation. Third party data is obtained from sources believed to be reliable. However, PCAC cannot guarantee that data's currency, accuracy, timeliness, completeness or fitness for any particular purpose. Certain sections of this commentary may contain forward-looking statements that are based on our reasonable expectations, estimate, projections and assumptions. Forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance and involve certain risks and uncertainties, which are difficult to predict. Past performance is not a guarantee of future return, nor is it necessarily indicative of future performance. Keep in mind investing involves risk. The value of your investment will fluctuate over time and you may gain or lose money.