The Pros & Cons of Hiring a Tax Professional

in Financial Planning by

For the majority of high-income earners who have financial complexities such as business ownership, home ownership, investments and more, hiring an accountant can make sense.

However, some entrepreneurs and retirees prefer to face tax time alone, despite having significant investments or multiple streams of income.

What is it that makes someone hire a tax professional versus handling their own returns? Let’s look at the pros and cons.

Pros: Time and Money

Despite being a financial writer who enjoys handling money, I hire an accountant to do my taxes. I do this so that I can have a professional double check my business income and expenses.

I’m always concerned about properly listing my business deductions, and I want a second set of eyes to look over everything and make sure my deductions are accurate. I also want someone on my side should I get audited; someone I know well who has detailed knowledge of my personal and business transactions. I’m not alone.

John Schmoll, who owns the popular website Frugal Rules and co-owns a copywriting business with his wife, said, “As our business grew I felt that I was overlooking opportunities to save money in different areas, and that I really wasn’t doing our tax situation justice. We ended up hiring a CPA three-to-four years ago and, in all honesty, it’s one of the best things we’ve done for our business.”

John went on to say that his accountant saves them thousands of dollars each year by taking advantage of deductions that John wasn’t aware of previously.

This also brings up the great point that it can be good to work with someone to toss around ideas on how to lower your taxes. After a rather high tax bill this year, I’m already working with my accountant to plan for my 2017 taxes to find ways to reduce the taxes I may owe next year. Although I’m well versed when it comes to finances because of my job, I still enjoy working with a professional to see what he recommends to lower the amount I owe.

For Grayson Bell, the owner of the successful company iMark Interactive, hiring an accountant was more about saving his already limited time. He said, “I used to do my own taxes, but then realized I could better spend my time and energy running my business and gaining more clients.”

This makes sense too. It takes me hours just to gather and prepare all of the paperwork to send to my accountant. Plus, my accountant can complete my returns in way less time than it would take me. I’d rather focus on what I do best and outsource my taxes to someone who is an expert.

Cons: A Missed Learning Opportunity

You might assume that hiring an accountant is the way to go, especially for high income earners. That’s not always the best option, though. Although hiring an accountant does save time and has the potential to save money if you’re uncertain of deductions that apply to you, it still can be a pricey service. Plus, you miss out on personally learning about the tax code, which can prove useful in the future.

That’s a big reason why Greg Johnson decided to file his own taxes. Greg and his wife, Holly, run a successful blog called Club Thrifty. Holly was recently featured in Forbes for earning $225,000 from freelance writing income alone, not including her and Greg’s blog business income. Add that to owning an LLC taxed as an S-corp and having two rental properties, and many would assume the Johnsons definitely need an accountant.

However Greg says, “Even though we earn more than we used to, I still choose to do my own taxes. In addition to saving money on accountant fees, doing my own taxes has taught me a lot about both my personal finances and my business.”

When you outsource this, you can give up the chance to learn about new tax laws and deductions that might affect your personal and business taxes.

My father-in-law, Darryl Alford, is another example of a high net worth individual who has filed his own taxes for over 50 years. Despite having rental property, complex investments, and multiple streams of income, he still manually completes the tax paperwork every year. When I asked him why he’s done his own taxes all these years (he’s 75) he said, “I just started doing it years and years ago when it was simple, and I just grew into it as it got more complex. Each year, I learned more and more, so it was just a gradual process.”

As you can see, deciding whether to hire an accountant is a very personal decision, and depending on how complex your finances are, you may want to put some thought into whether one is right for you.

Do you file your own taxes or do you hire an accountant? Why or why not?

[Taxes are a small part of the larger financial picture. Register for Personal Capital’s free financial tools to see if you are on track with your long-term financial goals]

The following two tabs change content below.

Catherine Alford

Catherine Alford is an award winning personal finance writer who contributes to several online publications including The Huffington Post, top personal finance blogs, and her own site, She received a B.A. from The College of William and Mary and an M.A. from Virginia Tech. When she is not reading and writing, she is taking care of her young twins. Follow her on twitter @BudgetBlonde.


  1. Peter

    I’m 47 and I’ve always done my own taxes. I started out doing them manually on paper. With additional investments and the dramatically increased complexity of the tax code, I now can’t imagine doing them without TurboTax. With TurboTax and my relatively simple income situation (no self-employment complexity), it’s hard to imagine paying someone else to do them.

  2. Accounting Services Online

    Awesome tips for the Start-ups!I really appreciate this information. As an experienced accountant, i know the worth of this information. Great, keep it up.

  3. Ellie Davis

    Thank you for suggesting hiring someone that is going to be able to toss around different ideas to lower your taxes. My husband and I are considering hiring someone this tax season but haven’t found anyone yet. I think we need to do some research and find the right accountant for my little family.

  4. Rosie Beckett

    My husband and I have noticed that doing taxes takes us a long time and we don’t know much about taxes, so we are thinking of hiring an accountant to do our taxes this year. You make a great point that it will help you to save time and money because they will be able to get you the biggest tax return possible. Also, I think that the aspect of saving time is a huge benefit for us so that we can focus our energy on other aspects of our life.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Disclaimer. This Website may contain links to third-party websites. These links are provided solely as a convenience to you and does not imply an affiliation, sponsorship, endorsement, approval, investigation, verification, or monitoring by PCAC of the contents on such third-party websites. Please be advised that PCAC is not responsible for the content of any website owned by a third party.