When should
you retire?

Find out for free.

It only takes a few minutes and
it’s 100% free.

Are you on track to retire when you want?

Find out for free.

Sign up for Personal Capital’s free
tools to use Retirement Planner™.

Get access to free professional-grade financial tools like our Retirement Planner™ today.

It only takes a few minutes
and it’s 100% free.

Close

Daily Capital

Term vs Whole Life Insurance: Which is Better?

No one likes to think about it, but at some point we’re all going to die. Just as taxes are inevitable, so is death. While that may not be the best or most desirable thing to think over, the beauty is that you can start planning for it now.

According to LifeHappens.org, there are very few circumstances in which you will not find yourself needing life insurance. That even covers single individuals needing to fund final expenses and/or medical bills.

Best tool out there to understand your financial health, cash flow, and retirement goals. Love Personal Capital!

Unfortunately, when you discuss life insurance there can be a myriad of opinions that come into play. This largely goes back to the number of options available in the life insurance space and the way some insurance plans are sold.

What is Term Insurance?

There are two major forms of life insurance: term life insurance and whole/universal life insurance. Term policies are issued for a given period of time, such as 10, 20 or 30 years. If you die during the term, your designated beneficiaries will receive the death benefit. If you don’t die during the term, the policy will expire when the term ends and no benefits will be paid.

Term insurance is sometimes referred to as “pure” life insurance because its sole purpose is to provide financial protection for your dependents in the event of your death. Unlike whole/universal life insurance, a term policy has no value other than the death benefit.

One of the biggest benefits of term life insurance is that premiums remain the same throughout the term of the policy, which provides cost certainty. Also, term insurance is usually less expensive than whole/universal life — often much less expensive. The biggest drawback is that if you don’t die during the term of the policy, neither you nor your beneficiaries will receive any benefit.

It’s usually smart to choose a term that will cover the years while you’re working and your beneficiaries will need income if you have passed away. For example, if you’re 35 years old, you might choose a 30-year term to provide income for your spouse while children are still in the house and until he or she qualifies for Social Security. Keep in mind that the longer the term, the more expensive a policy usually is.

What Is Whole Life Insurance?

Whole and universal life insurance differ from term insurance in that they last for your whole life. With this extended period, premiums are considerably more expensive. The other major benefit whole/universal life insurance offers is that the premiums have the capability of growing as cash value over the life of the policy. This growth is generally tax deferred and can be accessed over the life of the policy, with some exceptions. However, if you do not touch this cash prior to passing away, it is disbursed to your beneficiaries in addition to the face value of the policy.

Excess whole life premiums are not invested in the stock market — rather, they are invested at the insurance company’s discretion. This does mean that you will likely be hampered in regards to the return you will enjoy through a whole life policy, but you also get the benefit of having level terms for your life, assuming you hold the policy until passing. 

In terms of purchasing whole life insurance, most people will be better served by purchasing it at a younger age in order to secure lower premiums. The premiums will still be higher than with term insurance, but you’ll be able to lock in a lower premium rate. Those who do wait to purchase whole life insurance at a much older age are doing so in order to solidify the “burial coverage” that whole life insurance is sometimes referred to as.

How Is Universal Life Different from Whole Life?

Universal life insurance, much like whole life, is coverage that is considered permanent in nature. You can also build up cash value in a universal life policy like you can a whole life policy. The similarities between the two basically stop there.

The biggest difference between whole life and universal life is how the premiums are handled and how the excess is managed. With universal life, you can make premium payments at any time you wish and in any amount you wish – thus pointing to the flexibility it offers. This is why some refer to universal policies as adjustable life insurance. The important point to remember is that if you cease making premium payments or withdraw built up cash value, this can impact your coverage amount, leading up to needing to put more cash in or even surrendering the policy.

Assuming you make excess premium payments, which is generally how these products are sold, they go into some sort of investment product. Those investments can be anything from stocks to bonds to mutual funds/annuities, but they’re restricted by what the particular insurance company offers. Options vary widely from company to company based on their investment philosophies and what they want to make available to their policyholders, which makes it critical to find a company and policy that aligns with your investing preferences. If you are able to find such a match, an investment-oriented universal life policy provides the potential for a better return than what you’ll see in a whole life policy. Just remember that it also presents greater risk. The other major difference with universal policies is that they offer more transparency with regard to fees. 

Who Should Buy Permanent Life Insurance?

Whole and universal life insurance has earned a bad reputation over the years as many life insurance agents and companies sell these policies as something they shouldn’t be – an investment. Some of that criticism is well deserved and some of it isn’t. The question is: What does your personal situation call for?

Insurance companies base premium amounts on actuarial tables that are weighted by age and health factors. Obviously, the older a person is, the more likely they are to die, which causes the cost of life insurance to be exorbitantly high. Because of this, if you’re older and approaching retirement or are in retirement, then purchasing permanent life insurance likely isn’t going to be the wisest use of your funds. This is especially the case if you’re able to self-insure through other investments and have a way to provide for your family members upon passing and cover your financial responsibilities at death. If that is not the case, then purchasing permanent life insurance is something that could be considered, in addition to looking at viable alternatives such as long-term care insurance.

If you’re wanting permanent life coverage, then the best alternative is to purchase coverage as young as you can. While you can still get lower premiums under the term alternative, the term will eventually expire. Similar coverage under a whole life plan will cost more, but it also guarantees the death benefit for your entire life. Again, it all goes back to your personal situation and what fits best. 

Why Life Insurance Is A Bad Investment

Having adequate life insurance coverage is an essential part of retirement planning, but it should by no means be viewed as an investment. Life insurance was never meant to be an investment, but something to provide for final needs and for your family members once you do pass away.

Beyond the misuse of the whole/universal life product, the other major problem behind using permanent life insurance as an investment is that you have no control over how the funds are invested. While you might find a company that fits alongside your general investment philosophies, you still have little to no control over how excess premiums are allocated and invested. Accessing cash value comes with a cost: the lowering of the face value (or death benefit) of the policy.

Accessing cash from a universal life policy could cause the cash value to go lower than the associated costs and thus harm the policy. Also, any loans taken out against these policies incur interest, which must be paid back. If you’re young that might not be a problem, but many in retirement aren’t seeking to pay back loans on things such as life insurance.

Purchasing life insurance is a personal decision. Don’t allow sales materials to convince you that one type is better than another, but consider the needs of you and your family.

The content contained in this blog post is intended for general informational purposes only and is not meant to constitute legal, tax, accounting or investment advice. You should consult a qualified legal or tax professional regarding your specific situation. Keep in mind that investing involves risk. The value of your investment will fluctuate over time and you may gain or lose money.

Any reference to the advisory services refers to Personal Capital Advisors Corporation, a subsidiary of Personal Capital. Personal Capital Advisors Corporation is an investment adviser registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training nor does it imply endorsement by the SEC.

Better financial lives through technology and people.
Icon Close

To learn what personal information Personal Capital collects, please see our privacy policy for details.